Earlier work · Auto Technician Web Portal
Technical Information System 2.0
- Role
- UX designer on a team of 3
- Client
- BMW (Technical Information System for BMW and MINI)
- Year
- 2017
- Platform
- Responsive web portal (desktop, tablet, mobile) and desktop CMS
The Story
In 2017 I flew to New Jersey with one of our VPs and a Digital Transformation Director to meet with BMW about a potential project. BMW was looking to redesign its Technical Information System into a more robust, responsive web application. The Technical Information System, or TIS, provides technicians, parts personnel, and administrators with access to Service Bulletins, Parts Manuals, and other documentation needed to diagnose issues and perform repairs on BMW and MINI vehicles. They also wanted to create a new content management system for TIS.
Our team of 3 was first tasked with creating a proposal.
The Proposal: Wireframes
At the beginning of my design process, I created wireframes for the proposal to give BMW a quick visual of what we could accomplish.
During our stakeholder and technician interviews, we learned it was very important for technicians to be able to view TIS on their mobile devices. Therefore we decided to create mobile wireframes for the proposal.
While in New Jersey I initially used Axure to create low-fidelity wireframes. I wanted to get something in front of the potential client while we were onsite so we could get quick feedback, and Axure's drag-and-drop functionality allowed me to do just that.
After receiving feedback from the stakeholders, I then created medium-fidelity wireframes using Sketch for the proposal.
- Homepage Sketch wireframe
Homepage Sketch Wireframe
Proposal wireframe 2 of 4
Proposal wireframe 3 of 4
Proposal wireframe 4 of 4
CMS Wireframes
I also designed wireframes for the content management system to be used by administrators. We decided this was necessary as we wanted to show our approach to the CMS and give BMW an idea of what TIS could look like on desktop.
- Homepage for CMS admin
Homepage for CMS Admin
We landed the project! Interviews
Once we were awarded the project, I decided to conduct more user interviews in order to gain a deeper understanding of the technicians' needs and pain points. I also needed to speak with parts and warranty personnel since I learned they used the TIS application as well.
We traveled back to New Jersey for the project kickoff, and I visited the BMW dealership in New York City on the last day. During that time I interviewed three technicians, a parts personnel employee, and a warranty personnel employee.
The project lead for BMW was the one and only CMS administrator, and we decided to work on the CMS after redesigning the technician experience since they were the primary user.
A few technician questions
- Describe your workflow when servicing a vehicle.
- What is your process for finding Service Bulletins?
- What is your process for finding Parts Manuals?
- Where do you currently use TIS?
- Where would you like to be able to use TIS?
- What do you like about the current TIS application?
- What do you dislike about the current TIS application?
A few parts and warranty questions
- How do you currently use the TIS application?
- How often do you use TIS?
- Where do you use TIS?
- If you could wave a magic wand and change anything about TIS, what would it be?
For technicians, I was mostly interested in learning more about their chief workflow, locating Service and Parts Bulletins. I wanted to know what was most important to them and what their expectations were for the search functionality.
For parts and warranty personnel, I was mostly concerned with how they were using TIS, and how often.
Key Insights
- The current search functionality had VERY little data forgiveness.
- Techs want to be able to share bulletins with other techs, and specifically be able to copy links to send to parts personnel, as well as print documents.
- Techs constantly walk back and forth between their computer and vehicle to look at pics/diagrams.
- Techs mostly search for Service Bulletins, but one tech said he looked at parts bulletins 30% of the time.
- Techs expressed strong interest in view TIS on mobile devices, better search with more data forgiveness, and the ability to view a history of viewed Bulletins.
- Parts and warranty personnel did not use TIS often but said they wished it was more intuitive and user-friendly when they did.
Personas
Based on stakeholder (CMS admin) and user interviews I set up two personas. The personas allowed me to keep the user in the forefront of my mind throughout the design process. I also wanted something to refer to when design decisions were being discussed with business during sprint reviews. Each persona includes basic demographic information along with user behaviors, needs, pain points, and opportunities. Each persona was validated with the BMW project lead. One of the key new features that came from the personas was the ability to share Service Bulletins. This was extremely well received by the technicians because it would save them a considerable amount of time.
- Primary and secondary user personas
Primary and Secondary User Personas
User Flows
Next, I mapped out the users' steps in order to make sure we were guiding the user to the end goal as quickly as possible. I focused on the search functionality since it was the most widely used functionality and was causing the greatest amount of friction in TIS's current state. Mapping out the flows allowed me to identify the filter types users would need and what functionality was needed on the Service Bulletin profile page.
- Mapping the technician’s steps with sticky notes
Mapping the technician’s steps
- Technician user flow
Travis the Technician User Flow
User Testing
I traveled to two separate BMW dealerships near Atlanta to complete two rounds of qualitative usability testing. In each round, I tested 2-3 technicians using a mobile InVision prototype on my MacBook. With their permission, I recorded the screen and audio so I could reference them in creating a usability report. My goal was to get their feedback on navigation, new search functionality, and a new idea for creating sessions on upcoming work.
Insights
- Users had trouble finding the Saved Bulletins Manager
- Due to the current functionality of search in TIS, users did not know they could search by keyword.
- Users typically searched by model and series first.
- Tabs on Bulletins needed to prioritize Warranty and Parts Information.
- Sessions would not very useful.
- Users were very interested in training videos.
In response to the feedback, I moved the Saved Bulletins Manager, added placeholder text to the search input, prioritized model and series searches, and added training videos to TIS.
Revised mobile design after testing
UI Design
I used Sketch for the final screens and incorporated BMW's style guide into the design. For the technicians, I included desktop, tablet, and mobile designs with BMW and MINI styles. for the CMS administrator, I created desktop mockups only since they would always be using a company laptop to manage content, whether in the office or at home. I was very proud to provide BMW with fully responsive designs that allowed technicians to find content quickly and content administrators to manage content quickly.
- CMS admin user flow
CMS Admin User Flow
Mobile design 1 of 4
Mobile design 2 of 4
Mobile design 3 of 4
Mobile design 4 of 4
Tablet design 1 of 4
Tablet design 2 of 4
Tablet design 3 of 4
Tablet design 4 of 4
Desktop design 1 of 4
Desktop design 2 of 4
Desktop design 3 of 4
Desktop design 4 of 4
CMS Admin Designs
Most of the CMS administrator design work came at the end of the project since the BMW project lead was the sole user at that time. I flew back to New Jersey and sat with the project lead for a week so I could get rapid feedback on user flows and wireframes. This was extremely helpful since the business and user goals were perfectly aligned. I then returned to Atlanta and completed the UI designs.
CMS admin design 1 of 4
CMS admin design 2 of 4
CMS admin design 3 of 4
CMS admin design 4 of 4
What I Learned
This project was both challenging and fun. As someone who has limited automotive mechanical knowledge, I was a little worried about having to empathize with technicians. The good news is BMW was very open to the UX process, and the research required to gain knowledge about the users. I now have a greater appreciation for getting buy-in from clients.
One of the other most challenging aspects of this project was the design reviews. BMW has some very intelligent employees, and they asked thoughtful questions that forced me to explain my design decisions. That experience allowed us to make a better product and has been invaluable in my projects that followed.
- 2
- User Testing Rounds
- 865
- Screens
- 7
- Prototypes
- 1,000
- cups of coffee
See more of my work